Brief and informal analysis of different rollcage sim methods

Brief and informal analysis of different rollcage sim methods

everything done with 5mm mesh sizing

shells - external contact patch

 

image-20241104-155346.png
image-20241104-155444.png

 

solids - external contact patch

case 1

image-20241104-145552.png

 

image-20241104-145621.png

case 2

 

image-20241104-150154.png

 

image-20241104-150259.png

 

solids - tube contact patch

case 1

image-20241104-150844.png

 

image-20241104-150928.png

case 2

 

image-20241104-151123.png
image-20241104-151213.png

 

solids - fillets, tube contact patch

case 1:

image-20241104-153445.png

 

image-20241104-153600.png

case 2:

 

image-20241104-154159.png

 

image-20241104-154338.png

Conclusions:

note: conclusions are a little bit vibe based

  • Solids are probably preferable, since it reports similar (although slightly lower) stresses and you don’t have to use 1.4 sf - I feel like they increase the loading at the supports by a significant margin, I don’t know why though

  • Fillets actually induce higher stresses, I think berkley guy was trying to explain why, something with how without the fillets cause more shear stresses to build up or something, but fillets could be necessary for a more accurate sim

  • external contact patch behaves differently than applying force directly to tube, I don’t think one is necessarily better but it could be worth to just try either and use whichever one produces more favorable results..